Re: The Spore 100

by **bmpalmann** Thu Sep 09, 2010 1:47 am

OP needs a to be updated Vek... Neutral

by **Rikyudoo** Thu Sep 09, 2010 1:59 am

And also, i would like to nominate Jaconan, who left spore recently, and The88, one of the best at humanoids ( or maybe the best) and finally i nominate N-Minus

by **Shardna** Thu Sep 09, 2010 3:59 am

Vektrix wrote:Right, this thread is to decide something ONCE AND FOR ALL. Who are the best ONE HUNDRED Spore Creators of all time. This is something I've wanted to do for a while now, and I still don't know how, but here goes.

What criteria are we considering these people?

Obviously, by their ability in all creators and individual creators. However, you can use all sorts of criteria, from how helpful they are, to how inspirational they are (i.e. have great ideas that make you want to create). Perhaps their ability to organise a contest, or their contribution to the spore community as a whole. How good are their comments, how good are they at commenting. Basically, this list is to tackle as a whole their contribution to spore.

OK, how will the list be compiled?

This is the bit I have been wrestling with for a while. I know of about 25+ creators I would defo put in the list, but cannot decide the order, or the importance to assign to each criteria. I know some creators who are unsurpassed in one editor, yet cannot use another editor to save their life. Equally I know other creators who not brilliant in any editor, but as a whole are well above average in all. This bit is open to interpretition and discussion.

What now?

At this stage, I am not taking nominations for this list, I would like to work out the best method for deciding how to comile the list. Like I said, I think there are quite a few shoe-ins for the list (based on different criteria), but not even in my own mind can I put these in any serious order. So let us discuss this possibility of compiling such a list.

However, those wishing to be a judge, may put forward for their case.

The Panel
Vektrix
Sakiara
CopperLou
Rebecca1208
Arkanay
Andeavor
Nidking

Criteria:-
Creature:
Outfitter:
Building:
Vehicle:
Community Involvement:

Other criteria are being considered.

Nominations

Aaarrrggg
AapBurger
AaronMk
alien7249
Andeavor
AngryZealot
Antarcticas
arastoph
Arkanay
AtariMethod
axell13

bcrane
BellaBlim
Berbert77
Bluhman
bmpalmann
Brad_Barron

CalamariM
Cecil_090
Ceece
Chamäleon
Chaoskampfkeks
codyr2391
Conswella
CopperLou
Creepers79
Cyana
cwarloe

Dadltondmd
dananddna
DandLProductions
DareWrek
Darthmidget
DDG-995
delayedreaction
DH106
DiabloDog
Didzo
Digi-P
Dino589
Ditymeat
DonLafontaine
DonOu812
Doomnova
DragonOfDeath
Drahn

ELolli
Enderhenne
Enry03
Eppendix
Ezrie

Felix78
Firesoul135
flamestar
foreverpiping
Fotosynthesis

G3NJI
Granite25
Greenneutron
Grimbot
Gryphon57

Hilight
Himmelslaub
hk1x1
Hydro_Glyph

Icedmask
Imaginea
Issenkraal

JAkster666
jamesgelfand
Jemily62
John_Freeman
Jomeaga
jonathanrex1
Jondree
JRsilverfoxx1390
juttaponath

Kai-Uwe79
Karl-EL
Kevin92
Kismet-Scar
klugist
Knoxinton
krakenmk
Kuzuki
kyle_r93

lazywnch
LOLAJANE
LordofDestiny

M5000
masscolder
MaudDibb
Milanopiano
MjrGlory
Moejoe18
Molotovcoketail
Mootacoo
Mouthwash
Mudokon117
Mushroomking1
Mysteryem

nachoproblem
Nadal6940
Nethellus
Nidking
nitrocroc

Omnilogical
Ozraptor4

Parkaboy
Pezzalis

Radick
Rantalia
Rebecca1208
Remypas
Rennar
Reyes1
riederman
Ringeltree
rungan
Ryuujin

Sakiara
Sayalle
sensimelio
Serevanth
SharnaSanveech
Shattari
Slartibartfast38
snuitergup
StarUniter

TALK2myHAND
TanjaH
TarsTarkas
techno605
techtor
TheGuy185
thezethrock
thiefers
Thobewill
TnT-Productions
tomanomanous
tuinahvuni

UberScribe
UltimateZob
Ursidae

v_ware
Vektrix
vikyna
Vilageidiotx
Virakotxa

Warboss92
warcriminal666
werderfan2012
world_piece

xDoomsoulx
Xervantez

zachd94
Zaroas
Zellex
Zonagirl

Gosh well I can think of so many people that make wonderful creations. Here's what I like to nominate.

Reyes1 (Cause he creates so many good oddball and scary creations. Plus he's awesome)
Copperlou (Cause this person did a fantastic job on the aeon creatures)
Rebecca (For her series and dragons. Plus she's very friendly ^^)
DevilsMayCare (Cause he makes great adventures. Check them out if you want)

That's whom I pick anyway.

-Shardna

Ps. How come my name is not there? Was I not good enough?

by **Zaroas** Thu Sep 09, 2010 6:36 am

Oh yay, I'm on the list!

Anywyas, I'd like to nominate the following:
Nicholas_Cap - A great creator and a very friendly person.
Jat371 - A great guy who's very good at making adventures, as well as buildings for the IAE.
HollowKnight - While she(?) was active, she(?) was one of the greatest creators I have ever seen.

So... Yeah.

by **cwar** Thu Sep 09, 2010 10:25 am

this sounds great!
although i have no chance of winning The Spore 100 - Page 8 381110

I'd also like to nominate Graxiplon

by **bmpalmann** Sun Oct 10, 2010 3:28 am

We're very good at coming up with these ideas. But we never carry them through.
Has the panel actually started judging or has this kinda stopped.
Either way i'm willing to help with this.

by **Arkanay** Sun Oct 10, 2010 3:32 am

bmpalmann wrote:We're very good at coming up with these ideas. But we never carry them through.
Has the panel actually started judging or has this kinda stopped.
Either way i'm willing to help with this.

Unfortunatly, it has stopped at the moment.

Nonetheless, the project is here to be picked up whenever is desired to do so.

by **bmpalmann** Sun Oct 10, 2010 3:34 am

What do you seriously think the chances of that happening are Ark?

My offer for being a judge still stands either way

by **Arkanay** Sun Oct 10, 2010 3:35 am

bmpalmann wrote:What do you seriously think the chances of that happening are Ark?

I don't worry over it.

Either we don't feel like it and don't do it, or we feel like it and carry it through.

And as I said, it is here to be used when we find fit. So nothing was lost.

by **Shiny_Glass** Sun Oct 10, 2010 5:31 pm

I think you should add the creator..

Bites_His_Nose.
He is beyond amazing.

by **bmpalmann** Sun Oct 10, 2010 10:17 pm

Okay this is the list of people who have been nominated but not added to the OP

B1ack_Blob
Graxiplon
Glance
moe289
Ecko09
Gmaster101
The88
N-Minus
DevilsMayCare
Nicholas_Cap
Jat371
HollowKnight
bongobongo123
Wonny3SW
Iraultza87
Twarda
Mr.Modest
MrMand
Psychichazard
GodisCrying
snikrept
TorgOwl
Goatface
abadaba18
tygerlim
Word5
nickuloos
Sethan777
Manicmoose
Simago624

by **Arkanay** Sun Oct 10, 2010 10:25 pm

Thanks, Ben. I have added them to the OP.

by **Vereor** Mon Oct 11, 2010 12:22 am

Im on this list? The heck...

by **bmpalmann** Mon Oct 11, 2010 3:30 am

Arkanay wrote:Thanks, Ben. I have added them to the OP.

At last! I've asked Vek to this ages ago, but i figured that making that list would help Wink

by **Kevin92** Mon Oct 11, 2010 5:20 am

would be cool if we can start with the project, soon Very Happy

by **War** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:14 am

Woah, never looked at this till today.

Out of curiosity, who was drunk enough to nominate me? ;P

by **Xaesheir** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:25 am

Still no mo289?! D:

BLASPHEMY!!!

by **bmpalmann** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:36 am

xDoomsoulx wrote:Still no mo289?! D:

BLASPHEMY!!!

Isn't it moe289? Cos he was nominated... unless someone made a spelling error.
@Kevin: I wish they'd start as well Rolling Eyes

by **LoD** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:37 am

bmpalmann wrote:
xDoomsoulx wrote:Still no mo289?! D:

BLASPHEMY!!!

Isn't it moe289? Cos he was nominated... unless someone made a spelling error.
@Kevin: I wish they'd start as well

it's mo289 not moe289 Smile

by **Kevin92** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:38 am

http://www.spore.com/view/myspore/mo289 Wink

by **bmpalmann** Mon Oct 11, 2010 8:39 am

Damn, well blame the person who originally nominated mo289 for the mess up Razz

I just complied the list of nominees.

by **Sakiara** Mon Oct 11, 2010 6:37 pm

We have actually judged some people, but like Ark said, it stopped Sad

by **bmpalmann** Mon Oct 11, 2010 6:43 pm

Well then lets try and get some more momentum for this to start again! Wink

by **Vektrix** Mon Oct 11, 2010 7:08 pm

Sorry, I feel like this is my fault... I am great at ideas, but not always great at carrying them through. Sad

I agree, this must still be done though. Thumbs Up

by **bmpalmann** Mon Oct 11, 2010 10:41 pm

Not to be too cheeky, but i still believe that the judging panel is missing a vehicle specialist... so even if it's not me, find a vehicle specialist you'll need one to evaluate vehicle building skills. Something which, no offence intended, can't be done to the fullest extent by creature and building specialists.
So i'd suggest approaching someone like War for that.

EDIT: I'm pointing this out for reasons of legitimacy only, as those who don't create vehicles are generally unaware of people like Iraultza87 the founder of the IAE several members of which are on the list. I hope you get what i mean

by Sponsored content